Okay, last night I was ready to cry. I could not get my pictures to look right. I worked with the white balance, thinking that would fix it, but it made it worse. Either the picture was too reddish or too blue-y.
My husband suggested that we take the same picture with the same settings on both cameras and check them side by side.

This is the original Olympus camera, which is what I am used to seeing.
This is what the new camera's picture looked like. Washed out, with the red tinge.

I didn't want have to take the camera back, I was really starting to bond with my little silver camera. The interface is soooo much easier to work with, and the LCD is ginormous! I love it!! I want it to love me back!!
Anyway, we started reading the instruction manual, and found out there are "Scenes". Which means they are pre-programmed setting for certain situations. For example, inside lighting, outside, sporting events, candlelight etc. So I decided I would give it one last try this afternoon.
As I was scrolling through all the "Scenes" I found "Cuisine" Hilarious!
But it is actually configured for close up still life. Bingo! I think I found what I was looking for. Now the colors are a little richer than the older camera, but I think I like it! Finally!! I can keep my cutie camera!